SIMoN
  Sanctuary Integrated Monitoring Network
Monitoring Project

Central coast trawl impact and recovery project: a collaborative fisheries study

Principal Investigator(s)

  • James Lindholm
    California State University, Monterey Bay
  • Mary Gleason
    The Nature Conservancy

Funding

  • Ocean Protection Council
  • MBNMS
  • CSUMB
  • The Nature Conservancy
Start Date: September 01, 2008

The trawl impact and recovery study is a collaborative effort, bringing together TNC (owner of trawl permits), trawlers, and ROV researchers. This is part of a five-year study, which began in 2009. Funded by the Ocean Protection Council/State Coastal Conservancy, private funding, and in-kind match from partners, this project brings together a diverse group of stakeholders, including: CSU Monterey Bay, Marine Applied Research and Exploration (MARE), MBNMS, NMFS Northwest Science Center, West Coast Groundfish Observer Program, Moss Landing Marine Labs, and several local fishermen (T. Maricich, E. Ewing, D. Wainscott, M. Tognazzini, M. Leary and G. Fox).

Although it is clear that trawling impacts the seafloor, little is known about the nature of the impacts or the patterns of recovery in soft bottom habitats. These habitats make up almost 80% of the continental shelf in California. And while some might think that these deep, soft-bottom communities are vast wastelands of sand, silt or mud, in fact they are quite complex, often with a high level of biogenic structure.

The objective of this five-year project was to quantify the impacts and recovery rates in unconsolidated sediments under different levels of trawling effort to inform management of the fishery. Specifically, the parameters assessed were:
Micro-habitat structure
Mobile invertebrates
Sedentary invertebrates
Infauna
Fishes

Using an actual fishing vessel, the Donna Kathleen, scientists and fisherman deployed trawls and an ROV to assess the changes in areas with and without trawling, then tracked how those areas changed through time, relative both to themselves and each other.

Monitoring Trends

  • Prior to the trawling effort, the control and experimental plots had similar percentages of bioturbated habitat (both about 80%).
  • Effects of the trawling 2 weeks and 6 months after the trawls are still pending analyses.

Study Parameters

  • Disturbance
  • Diversity
  • Habitat
  • Substrate characterization

Study Methods

Trawling occurred beyond California maritime limits off Point Buchon. Treatment plots were located along the inner edge of the RCA trawl closure. Sites were initially prospected using an ROV in September 2008. Baseline data were collected with the ROV and grab samples in September 2009. Grabs provided data on infaunal invertebrates and sediment grain size. The ROV provided views of seafloor microhabitats, epifaunal invertebrates, and benthic fishes.

Four plots were trawled and an additional four plots served as controls (they were not trawled). All eight were at similar depths (160-180 m deep) and consisted of a 300 m width and 1000 m length. Three 300-m long transects spanned the length of the plot. Multiple grab stations were also inside each plot.

Low intensity, directed trawling took place in October 2009 (trawled twice over the same area). In November 2009 ROV transects and grab samples were collected. This was also repeated in May 2010, 6 months after the trawling.

Figures and Images

Figure 1. Map indicating the location of the 8 study plots.


Figure 2. Design of sampling within the trawled plots. Controls were similar but lacked trawling.


Figure 3. Observed changes to-date between trawled and non-trawled plots.


Figure 4. Timeline for the five-year project.


Documents

  • Lindholm et al. (2011)
    Central Coast Trawl Impact and Recovery Study: 2009-2010 Summary Report. Report to the California Ocean Protection Council. March 7, 2011.
    980 KB

  • Lindholm et al. (2012)
    Central Coast Trawl Impact and Recovery Study: 2009-2011 Summary Report. Report to the California Ocean Protection Council. 31 January 2012.
    PDF Paper 1.5 MB

  • Lindholm et al. (2013)
    Lindholm J., Gleason M., Kline D., Clary, L., Rienecke S., Bell M, Kitaguchi, B. 2013. Central Coast Trawl Impact and Recovery Study: 2009-2012 Final Report. Report to the California Ocean Protection Council. January 31, 2013.
    PDF paper 1.8 MB